Cookbook of the Week: Turtle Island by Sean Sherman
Suzanne Podhaizer • November 19, 2025
Book cover for

Last week, I was shopping at the renowned Northshire Bookstore in Manchester, Vermont. Typically, when immersed in a well-stocked cookbook collection, I have a hard time deciding which volume (or volumes) to bring home. This time, I only had eyes for Turtle Island.

Written by Sean Sherman, founder and chef of the non-profit Minneapolis restaurant, Owamni, along with co-authors Kate Nelson and Kristin Donnelly, the book shares recipes from indigenous peoples as far north as Alaska and as far south as Southern Mexico.

To showcase the native foods of these regions, the book leaves out post-colonial ingredients. You won’t find dairy products, cane sugar, chicken or wheat in these pages.

What you will find instead are dishes that center corn, squash, legumes, nuts and seeds, foraged plants and game meats. To those of us who are accustomed to “American cuisine” that focuses primarily on European ingredients, these recipes hold revelations. Cedar-Maple Baked Beans, for instance, are simmered with a piece of wood in the pot, which is removed before serving. There are also recipes for preparing beaver and moose, and for cooking things we walk by daily in warm weather without realizing that they’re edible. For instance, milkweed pods, which are blistered in a bit of sunflower oil, and sumac, a plant with red cones composed of fuzzy sour fruits, which grows alongside hundreds of miles of New England highways.

To begin the section on New England, Sherman deals with the more brutal aspects of the circumstances surrounding the holiday we refer to as Thanksgiving. It should be required reading for all of us. Following that, he shares recipes for Quahog and Corn Chowder seasoned with powdered wild leeks, Wild Mustard and Root Veggie Salad with Sunflower Dressing, and Blueberry Leather.

In the five years that I owned a small, 22-seat restaurant in Montpelier, Vermont, we offered 100 different, deeply researched menus. In the decade since, I’ve grown and cooked with flour corn, heirloom squash and dozens of types of beans in my garden, and foraged for wild leeks, mushrooms, roots and flowers to use in my kitchen. The history and current reality of native foods is so rich that in all that time cooking and eating, I’ve never made nor encountered any dishes like the ones Sherman shares.

I mention that only to point out that this book is so rich and diverse and deep that the most accomplished scholars and cooks will nevertheless find many new things herein. Nobody should hesitate to add it to their collection.

Book cover for Mother Tongue by Gurdeep Loyal, with bright pink and white floral design and title text
By Suzanne Podhaizer February 10, 2026
Mother Tongue: Flavours of a Second Generation by Gurdeep Loyal
Book cover of “The Nordic Cook Book” with a blue sky and Arctic landscape background
By Suzanne Podhaizer December 16, 2025
The Nordic Cook Book by Magnus Nilsson
Cover of The New York Times New England Heritage Cookbook, brown background with red berries and a cream jug.
By Suzanne Podhaizer November 5, 2025
New England Heritage Cookbook by Jean Hewitt
Book cover of James Peterson’s Splendid Soups, showing a bowl of soup on a blue background.
By Suzanne Podhaizer October 29, 2025
Cookbook of the Week: Splendid Soups by James Peterson
Book cover of Greenfeast: Autumn, Winter by Nigel Slater, showing a plated roasted squash dish.
By Suzanne Podhaizer October 9, 2025
Cookbook of the Week: Greenfeast: autumn, winter by Nigel Slater
Cookbook cover for All About Braising with a braised meat dish and a bay leaf
By Suzanne Podhaizer October 2, 2025
Cookbook of the Week: All About Braising by Molly Stevens
Cover of Vegetarian Planet cookbook with colorful vegetables and title text by Didi Emmons
By Suzanne Podhaizer August 27, 2025
Cookbook of the Week: Vegetarian Planet by Didi Emmons
Book cover of Madhur Jaffrey’s An Invitation to Indian Cooking, featuring a woman in a sari with food on a table
By Suzanne Podhaizer August 21, 2025
The current Cookbook of the Week is An Invitation to Indian Cooking by Madhur Jaffrey
Book cover titled
By Suzanne Podhaizer August 6, 2025
This week’s cookbooks is Richard Hart Bread: Intuitive Sourdough Baking
Green painted glass jar on a blue patterned plate on a wooden table, with a blurred café background
By Suzanne Podhaizer July 31, 2025
Learn the difference between fermenting and pickling!